In a significant acknowledgment by the South Korean government, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission has revealed violations of fundamental human rights within its intercountry adoption processes. According to the commission’s findings, these violations occurred largely due to the absence of a comprehensive legislative framework, insufficient oversight, and non-compliance with administrative procedures.
Over the past several decades, South Korea has been one of the largest sources of intercountry adoptions. An investigation, predicated on extensive information gathering and interviews, assessed the adoption records of four major agencies, reviewing petitions from 367 adoptees sent abroad between 1964 and 1999.
The issues stem, in part, from South Korea’s historical context, as a nation grappling with both post-World War II and the Korean War devastations and then rampant economic challenges. The government vested heavily in intercountry adoptions as an economically expedient alternative to domestic child welfare strategies. It is suggested that South Korea’s “hurry hurry” ethos contributed to underdeveloped legal frameworks and rushed processes, severely impacting adherence to fundamental human rights.
Crucially, the government also relied heavily on private adoption agencies without adequate oversight, undermining the protection of children’s rights and complicating the regulation of these agencies. The results were a series of systemic flaws including inadequate consent and screening processes, falsification of records, and pressured adoptions driven by demand rather than the interest of child welfare.
The commission detailed eight specific violations:
- Lack of proper consent for adoption
- Fabrication of records, such as false reports of abandonment
- Tokenistic public notices for guardians
- Deliberate identity substitution
- Inadequate screening of prospective adoptive parents
- Neglect of guardianship duties
- Mass exportation of children to meet demand
- Compulsory donations related to adoption placements
In response to these findings, the commission has called for several remedial actions, including a government apology and enhancements to adoptee rights protections. The commission has also emphasized the need for South Korea to ratify the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Cooperation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption to enhance the safeguarding of children’s rights during such processes.
A pressing aspect of the commission’s report is its acknowledgment of the trauma experienced by adoptees, as pointed out by commission member Lee Sang Hoon during a press conference. Despite over 98 adoptees filing lawsuits against the government, only 56 were recognized as victims, pointing to potential gaps in judicial recognition of victims’ experiences.
The responsibility to correct the illegalities in intercountry adoptions is well-documented in international law. This encompasses rights to truth, annulment of unjust adoptions, the right to reparations, and implementation of truth mechanisms, underpinned by conventions like the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
For further details on this story, please refer to the original article on JURIST.