Mitigating SEC Enforcement Risks: Strategies for Whistleblower Carveout Language Compliance

When discussing the topic of whistleblower carveout language, far too often companies are found to be at odds with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Since 2015, the SEC has initiated almost two dozen enforcement actions for breaching whistleblower protection rules under Rule 21F-17(a). Predominantly, these actions have stemmed from language present in employee-facing agreements which purportedly discouraged reporting to the SEC. This article discusses three key steps to mitigate SEC enforcement risks related to whistleblower carveout language.

Firstly, taking a proactive stand to revise any prohibition or discouragement language in employee-facing documents can reduce future conflicts. Confidentiality and indemnification agreements are two such documents where potentially problematic language often resides. The ideal aim would be to ensure that all agreements highlight and emphasize an employee’s rights to report possible violations to the SEC. Similarly, it should make clear that employees are not required to notify the company before making any such disclosures.

Secondly, companies need to consistently train their internal personnel who draft, review, and administer these agreements. They need to be well-versed in the subject matter, understanding the detrimental effects of including enforceable carve-outs within these agreements. The importance of this cannot be understated, as failure to comply can result in significant penalties under SEC regulations.

Thirdly, regularly monitoring and revising compliance programs are crucial steps towards mitigating these risks. This includes re-evaluating the whistleblower reporting process to ensure that internal channels are not impeding the reporting to the SEC. The ultimate goal should be to establish a culture of compliance within the organization that does not deter but promotes responsible whistleblowing behavior.

It is clear that the SEC is keenly focusing on whistleblower carve-out language and corporate practices that may discourage whistleblowing activities. Therefore, businesses must pay heed, draft their agreements carefully, and ensure they do not infringe on any whistleblower protection laws. The argument is quite simple – words, indeed, matter.

For a more comprehensive understanding of the subject, refer to the full analysis provided by Proskauer – The Capital Commitment here.