Unreported Forgiven Debt of Supreme Court Justice Raises Tax Compliance Concerns

The Senate Finance Committee reported that U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has not repaid a $200,000 loan for a vehicle purchase from 1999. The committee’s memo indicates that the loan was originally $267,230 provided by Tony Welters, who is a friend of Thomas’. This loan was used to purchase a recreational vehicle (RV).

Antony Welters wrote a note in 2008 absolving Thomas of any future payments for the loan because the interest accumulated over the years was more than the value of the RV. However, an important aspect that arises from these findings is that Thomas did not report the forgiven loan on his 2008 Financial Disclosure Report. Any forgiven debt must be reported according to the U.S tax code.

Senate Finance Committee Chair Ron Wyden stated his concerns about the ethical implications associated with this forgiven loan. He urged Justice Thomas to clarify to the committee the exact amount of debt being forgiven and confirm whether it was properly shown in his tax returns and all taxes duly paid.

An article by the New York Times first disclosed the loan details in August this year. The Prevost Marathon model RV was featured in a 60 Minutes interview with Thomas, where he highlighted that he sometimes stayed in the vehicle overnight in Walmart parking lots during road trips across the U.S.

Throughout this year, Justice Thomas has drawn criticism over his financial disclosures leading Congress to consider a reform bill for ethical and disclosure requirements for Supreme Court justices. Thomas’ disclosures last year included questionable business trips with a billionaire, and a report by ProPublica alleged that he did not declare his attendance at a donor event hosted by the Koch network in 2018.