Lawyers’ Guide to Supervising AI: 7 Steps for Ensuring Accountability and Fairness in Legal Technology

The concept of supervision is far from new to professionals in various fields, lawyers included. But now, as these legal professionals find themselves in charge of overseeing AI technology, the key theme is accountability. The importance of this responsibility can’t be overstated, as it empowers lawyers to mould AI into a tool that promotes fairness and justice.

While we wait for industry and government bodies to devise official AI supervisory frameworks and audit processes, there are preparatory measures that you can take. The following seven steps serve as a guide for creating accountability in AI usage:

  1. Maintain a decision log. Documentation is crucial while using AI, especially when decisions are based on AI tool output. Keeping track of your decisions along with their rationale will serve as a reference for future improvements and as evidence if any issues arise.
  2. Record reliance on AI outputs. This expands on the previous point, asking you to detail all AI-generated conclusions you rely on, including the tool used and steps taken to validate its findings. Making note of the date and time helps in creating a chronological record in case of any legal disputes about your decision to use (or not use) AI.
  3. Fact-check and scrutinize AI-generated content. Like new associates at law firms, the work of AI needs diligent supervision. It’s critical to verify the accuracy, credibility, and completeness of AI outputs before finalizing your work. This not only upholds the integrity of the legal profession but also aids in refining AI technology.
  4. Address conflicts of interest. Documentation of possible conflicts arising from your firm, clients, AI tool vendors, AI models, and the source of data sets used to train AI demonstrates transparent and ethical conduct.
  5. Test various generative AI prompts. Trying out different methods of prompting an AI tool uncovers potential inconsistencies or discrepancies in its responses, helping you pinpoint underlying biases or shortcomings.
  6. Prevent and address biased outcomes. Collaborate with AI experts to identify sources of bias and develop counteractive remedies. Continuously monitor AI systems to detect and rectify any unintended biases promptly.
  7. Seek independent analysis for bias detection. Occasionally asking for an outside opinion on AI tool conclusions can reveal blind spots and biases unnoticed during internal evaluations.

Understanding AI supervision and accountability not only equips lawyers to use AI responsibly but also promotes AI technology’s fair and unbiased development. As lawyers adopt a comprehensive, transparent approach to AI supervision, companies and society at large stand to benefit in terms of improved efficiency and accuracy. Long-term advancements grounded in fairness and justice are also expected to follow.

It would be interesting to hear your thoughts on how lawyer supervision of AI differs from human supervision. What additional steps should lawyers take to ensure AI accountability?

For a more in-depth look at this topic, feel free to read the original article by Olga V. Mack, VP at LexisNexis and CEO of Parley Pro, a next-generation contract management company that has pioneered online negotiation technology, here.