Choreography and Copyright: What the Fortnite vs. Hanagami Case Reveals

The dance world was unprepared for the intriguing intellectual property conundrum stirred up when Congress amended the Copyright Act back in 1976. Legislation was put in place to extend copyright protection specifically to choreography, but the subsequent decades have yielded few significant cases elucidating the meaning and reach of these protections. This is starting to change, and surprisingly, the video game industry and a celebrity choreographer are at the heart of it.

The hook at the center of the unfolding legal drama is Fortnite, the popular online video game developed by Epic Games, and Kyle Hanagami, a renowned choreographer with a star-studded client list. According to Hanagami, Epic Games has appropriated a dance routine he created and copyrighted, named “How Long,” and used it as an in-game “emote,” visual gestures or dances that player avatars can perform in the game.

Seemingly straightforward, this case has led to legal debate about the nature of choreography itself and the granular question of what constitutes a protectable choreographic work. When Hanagami sued Epic for copyright infringement, the developer defended itself by claiming Hanagami’s work wasn’t distinctive enough to warrant protection and that the similarities weren’t substantial. The initial hearing saw the district court side with Epic Games.

However, on appeal, the Ninth Circuit court reversed the decision. A significant point in their argument was a critique of the district court’s approach to “dissect” Hanagami’s work into individual “poses”. They poignantly articulated that such a deconstructive methodology is “at odds” with the way that other art forms are assessed. After all, a painting is more than just individual brush strokes and notes in isolation do not compose a song. In the Ninth Circuit’s view, the work’s gestalt, or the ‘whole’ experience it provides, should be the basis of legal assessment.

The court also dismissed Epic’s claims that their use of just a “short” part of Hanagami’s dance didn’t constitute infringement. Instead, the Ninth Circuit emphasized that the importance of the copied choreography in the context of the larger work was crucial.

Though the case was returned to the district court for further proceedings, the Ninth Circuit’s detailed opinion represents an important development in copyright law as it pertains to the creative world of choreography. It provides insight and guidance on what is protectable in choreographic works, setting precedence on the scale and nature of infringement. As the world continues to evolve and the boundaries between different forms of media and art become increasingly blurred, keeping an eye on cases such as Fortnite vs. Hanagami may be crucial for anyone operating in creative and legal spaces.