California’s Commercial Loan Fee Ban: Navigating the Ambiguity of “Small Business” Definition

The term “small business” has always been an ambiguous term with varied definitions in different legal and business contexts. Now, this nebulous meaning takes center stage as a new ban on commercial loan fees in California brings its interpretation into question.

Starting in January, a new Californian law — Cal. Stat. ch. 881 (SB 666) — comes into force, and it will prevent “covered entities” from levying specified fees on a commercial financing transaction involving a “small business” or the owner of a “small business”. The original text of the law is relatively brief, but it’s filled with many defined terms, such as “commercial financing” and “covered entity”, thus making it complex due to its broad implications.

Despite the ban, there are several significant exemptions to the law. These include certain types and impacts of fees related to financing, and more specifics around who and what constitutes a “small business”. Given the complexity surrounding this issue, legal professionals should familiarize themselves with the details of the new law to ensure their clients can best navigate the upcoming business landscape.

The interpretation of “small business”, vital in the context of this law, remains unclear, which could cause potential legal hurdles and uncertainties for legal practitioners and businesses alike. This ambiguity could potentially impact the way in which the law will be applied and thus, its ultimate effectiveness. Legal commentator Allen Matkins highlights the need for clear definitions within the law and the potential pitfalls and complications that could result without them.

As we progress through the coming year, keeping abreast of the evolving legal interpretations of the law and the term “small business” will be crucial. Corporate legal departments and law firms alike should stay tuned as this situation evolves and should be prepared to advise their clients accordingly.