In the aftermath of Hamas’s attacks on Israel last month, an NYU Law student found themselves jobless as a result of expressing that the attacks were “necessary.” This issue continued with firms withdrawing offers from students who were members of groups that had declared the attacks as counter-offensive. There was one instance where a lawyer had even gone so far as to support Hitler. As a result, these incidents have led legal organizations to rescind job offers based on perceived controversial attitudes towards the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Biglaw is coming to terms with the complexities and challenges of differentiating between critiques of Israeli policy and antisemitism. This struggle has resulted in some firms deciding to issue a public letter laying blame on law school deans.
However, constructive action against antisemitism is being taken by some law firms. Nevertheless, most of the attempts have been perceived as general denouncements rather than concrete solutions, triggering a blame game with academics focused on combating antisemitism.
The intensity surrounding this issue increases when observing that the divergence in motivations despite seemingly identical calls or actions has been rampant. For instance, Marjorie Taylor Greene had initiated the effort to censure Rashida Tlaib for antisemitism, while concurrently she was seen addressing groups that had been founded by a denier of the Holocaust.
Sidley’s lawyer, Melat Kiros, responded by publishing a detailed piece criticizing the firms signing the letter, blaming them for confusing geopolitical commentary with antisemitism. Kiros stresses that criticism of Israel as a political entity should be considered as an expression of central political speech, calling it the “bedrock principle of a true democracy.” Yet, Kiros was fired by Sidley for the publication when she declined to withdraw it.
The complexity of these issues is exemplified by the precedent set by Sidley itself. The firm’s Middle East services include working in “each Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) country,” some of which do not officially recognize Israel. Nonetheless, the actions of both lawyers and firms underline the fact that the line between legitimate criticism of Israeli policies and antisemitism is indeed complex and challenging for legal professionals.