In a significant legal development, the Colorado Court of Appeals has upheld the state’s cap on noneconomic damages, ruling it does not violate the Seventh Amendment. The appeals court decision addressed what was considered an issue of first impression, maintaining the long-established understanding that the Seventh Amendment does not extend to state jurisdictions.
The case emerged from a lawsuit filed by plaintiff Jacqueline Gebert against Sears, Roebuck and its local home repair branch. Gebert was electrocuted by her stove, which the company had incorrectly wired, leading to the metal cooking surface being charged with equal voltage to an electrical outlet. Gebert, while washing dishes, placed a pan on the stove and was subsequently electrocuted, as outlined in the court’s opinion.
The plaintiff took exception to the noneconomic damages cap, contending that this contradicts the civil jury trial right under the Colorado constitution. Among the issues contested in this case was whether the state’s constitution guarantees the right to a civil jury trial as the United States Constitution does.
“Unlike the United States Constitution, the Colorado Constitution does not guarantee the right to a jury trial in civil cases”, this was stated during the court proceedings, reflecting previous precedent. Gebert also proposed that the court should reconsider previous rulings and recognize the civil jury trial right under the state constitution.
This noteworthy ruling emphasizes the distinction between state and federal jurisdictions in matters related to civil jury trials and the upper limit set on noneconomic damages.Further details of the case can be found in the report available at this address.