The UK Ministry of Justice recently published a report outlining its position on various human rights issues identified in judgments by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and UK courts. It also provided responses regarding ongoing matters such as the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023, issues in the Gender Recognition Act 2004 (GRA), and possible amendments to the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA).
As a member of the 46-country-strong European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR), the UK is committed to following judgments by the ECtHR’s decisions. At a domestic level, UK courts can also determine that certain laws are inconsistent with the ECHR under the HRA. If incompatibilities are found, the law must be adjusted to match ECHR standards. The Ministry’s report illuminates how these obligations have been met during the past year.
In the report, 16 ECtHR judgments that needed government attention were discussed. Significant matters involved the Northern Ireland Troubles Act and the Bill of Rights Bill. The Committee of Ministers reiterated its concerns about the Troubles Act, with the Ministry of Justice acknowledging that while certain aspects of the act can be contentious, they are necessary to provide more information and accountability to victims and their families. Future amendments will be made with this goal in mind.
The Bill of Rights Bill was also a topic of discussion. It aimed to clarify the balance between the UK’s courts, ECtHR, and Parliament. The report highlighted a specific case related to Article 13 of the ECHR, which provides the right to an effective remedy. However, plans for the Bill of Rights were halted, and now the government is considering alternative legislative options.
According to the report, five declarations of incompatibility were made by domestic courts during the reporting year. Of these, three remedial orders rectified the incompatibilities, two declarations were overturned, and two are still outstanding. One of these involves the GRA, which permits transgender individuals to legally change their gender. The requirement for individuals to prove they have a disorder before changing their gender was declared incompatible with the ECHR. The government intends to rectify this with a remedial order.
The report thus provides a comprehensive account of the UK government’s responses to human rights issues raised by the ECtHR and its domestic courts during the past year. It highlights the flexibility of the government in making legislative changes in accordance with human rights standards and the continuous process involved in monitoring and addressing human rights issues as they emerge.