In a significant ruling on November 7, 2023, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit concluded that California’s Prop 65 warning for glyphosate – the key ingredient in the widely utilized herbicide Roundup® – contravenes the First Amendment1. A cornerstone of the legal debate was the nature of the warning as compelled commercial speech.
The court held that the Prop 65 warning didn’t meet the standard of being “purely factual and uncontroversial”. Because of this, the warning should be subject to the intermediate level of scrutiny conventionally used to evaluate compelled commercial speech. For a compelled disclosure to be seen as constitutional under the intermediate scrutiny standard, it must not be more extensive than required to serve a substantial governmental interest and should straight-forwardly advance that interest.
This verdict could have a far-reaching impact on the regulation of product labeling and could potentially open avenues for similar legal actions in the future. Furthermore, this decision may set a precedent for how commercial speech — particularly compelled speech — is viewed and evaluated within the legal domain. This particular case also serves as a reminder for corporations to remain vigilant about the legal parameters and complexities of compelled commercial speech.
The discussions and developments related to glyphosate and Prop 65 are an important watch for legal professionals providing counsel to corporations engaged in the manufacture or use of substances similar to glyphosate. The evolving legal precedents will continue to influence liabilities, risk assessments, and compliance strategies for businesses in relevant sectors.