PFAS Litigation Trend: Lack of Standing Aids in Dismissal of Claims Against Tom’s of Maine and Colgate-Palmolive

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (S.D.N.Y) has recently reinforced a legal trend by dismissing PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) claims owing to a lack of standing. This decision pertains to a proposed class action complaint against Tom’s of Maine, Inc, and its majority shareholder, Colgate-Palmolive, accusing that Tom’s Wicked Fresh! Mouthwash products included PFAS. The claims were nevertheless dismissed without prejudice, enabling the complainants the opportunity to rectify their arguments and re-file in the future.

For those who are uninitiated, PFAS is a term that covers a wide range of man-made chemicals that have been widely used across a range of products owing to their resistance to water, oil, and heat.

There has been growing concern surrounding these substances due to potential links to health issues, thus leading to increasing lawsuits in the consumer product industry. The trend, however, as observed in this recent decision, tends to favor the dismissal of such claims, typically due to a lack of standing.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, in particular, seems to continue favoring dismissal, following a pattern which this legal case against Tom’s of Maine and Colgate-Palmolive very clearly upholds.

This legal trend is propelling the defendants in PFAS litigation to increasingly challenge the plaintiff’s standing, arguing that they cannot establish a concrete injury. Often, courts have found these challenges compelling, ruling in favor of dismissal. However, it is worth noting that such dismissals are generally without prejudice, leaving a possibility for plaintiffs to re-assert their claims following modification of the complaint.

For more detail on the specifics of this case, further information can be found at this legal news outlet.