In a recent ruling involving the City of Greater Sudbury, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) has deemed that corporations and firms, those similar to the City of Greater Sudbury, can be held accountable as an “employer” under Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). This is significant as the ruling has potential implications not only in Canada but, potentially, in other common-law jurisdictions as well.
The case, referenced as R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), centered around the tragic death of a pedestrian. The City had appointed a third-party as the project’s “constructor,” yet the SCC still deemed that the City could be held liable. The ruling indicates that the delegation of certain responsibilities to a third party does not absolve the primary entity – in this case, the City – of its obligations under OHSA.
This decision sets a new precedent that corporations and other organizations cannot simply rely on contractual arrangements to limit their liabilities under occupational safety legislation. Instead, these entities must demonstrate a tangible commitment to health and safety at all times and in all operational aspects.
The potential ramifications in jurisdictions beyond Canada’s borders will be worth monitoring. In any event, it’s clear that corporate counsel and management teams worldwide would do well to review their health and safety protocols to ensure compliance – with local legislative standards.
For further details about the specifics of the ruling in R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), see the full article by Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP.