In recent days, there’s a fervent discussion regarding the proposed bill by Senator Josh Hawley and Richard Blumenthal to remove Section 230 protections from Artificial Intelligence (AI). The Senators are reportedly pushing to ‘hotline’ the bill, a tactic that focuses on unanimous consent to fast-track a bill’s progress. For many observers, the outcomes of this legislation pose a serious threat to the internet as we know it, even if one is not a fan of AI or Section 230. (Bill Excerpt, Hotlining Glossary)
The crux of the controversy lies in the interpretation of Section 230’s protection of generative AI systems’ output. While many argue that the results, being from the company, do not constitute third-party speech and hence should not be shielded by Section 230, others maintain that the protections should extend to algorithmic output generated from third-party content (LawfareBlog, Techdirt).
Hawley and Blumenthal’s bill is criticized for its broad definition of generative AI and its expansive exemption clause. The term ‘generative AI’ could encompass various technologies, potentially even spell checking or grammar checking tools. Moreover, the suggested exemption hinges on ‘the use or provision’ of generative AI, which could lead to a loss of Section 230 protections for companies merely because of an AI tool suggesting edits to a post. It is feared that this substantial expansion in liability could impact the viability of hosting user content or offering certain tools.
Further concerns spring from the bill’s creation of a loophole for state laws and the potential damage to the US’s position in the global internet economy. Its explicit carving out of ‘state law’ may allow states to circumvent national protections, opening up potential avenues for ideologically motivated punishments. Furthermore, as Section 230 has been instrumental in positioning the US as a leader in the internet economy, stripping away these protections in the era of generative AI could equate to relinquishing leadership in the next tech revolution to other countries that maintain these safeguards. (Washington Post, Copia)
For further reading, here are more law-related stories from Techdirt: