Dismantling the ‘Good Fit’ Barrier: Combating Discrimination in Law Clerk Hiring

On most occasions, the hiring of law clerks is shrouded in a powerful phrase, the ‘good fit’. This terminology may raise specific connotations for hiring judges and their applicants, but its implications extend beyond the individual judges’ chambers, making a compelling impact throughout the legal profession. The ‘good fit’ tag is allotted to applicants whose personalities align with a judge’s characteristics or preference, often neglecting the candidates’ merit. This practice has led to a long-standing pattern of harmful discrimination, directly influencing the profession’s diversity. Yet, the magnitude of this situation seems largely unnoticed.

The attribute of being a ‘good fit’ is destructive to a significant degree due to its very nature. Judges seeking clerks with similar professional background, geographic location, and even political ideology as theirs often turbulently hurl talented candidates undeservedly away from a promising career. Women, the nonwhite, first-generations, the disabled, and everyone else who is regarded as an ‘other’ are engulfed in a whirlpool of bias stacked against them within this outdated heuristic, depriving the legal profession of potential talent. Aliza Shatzman, the President and Founder of The Legal Accountability Project, outlines these issues and emphasizes the need for change.

For a better understanding of the grave problems posed by this phrase, consider the biases against certain clerks that are veiled behind the seemingly harmless term. When a judiciary is predominantly white and male, as has been historically observed, the ‘best fit’ for a white male judge, especially as seen by the faculty-members of Top 14 law schools who assist in clerkship hiring, would be a white male applicant. This leads to a distinct marginalization of other sectors, perpetuating a cyclical degradation of diversity in the profession.

Indeed, law clerks are mostly overwhelmingly white and male, reflecting the systemic bias. Concrete statistics exemplify this deeply-rooted bias, with 79% of federal clerks and 72% of state court clerks in the 2019 graduating class being white, far outweighing the 67% of law school graduates who were white in the same year. NALP reports illustrate this lack of diversity in stark terms. These figures make it evident that there is a dire need for a change in the way hiring is approached so that the diversification within the legal profession expands, benefiting not just the profession but the society as a whole.

This situation is even more dire considering the career pathway provided by clerkship roles to prestigious roles such as prosecutors, public defenders, law firm associates, and even judges. With such a tangible impact on career progression, the bias in selection is gravely impeding a vast section from unlocking their career potential.

The bias is even more pronounced when considering the inaction of the judiciary to diversity initiatives. The federal judiciary, in particular, has no formal diversity initiatives and has no oversight over individual judges’ hiring. Furthermore, in circumstances of discrimination or harassment on grounds such as gender, gender identity, race, ethnicity, age, or disability status, the affected clerks find no legal recourse due to the judiciary’s exemption from anti-discrimination laws. A proposed legislation would, if passed, require reporting of diversity data among clerks.

Despite such barriers, there is increasing acknowledgment of the need to diversify the cohort of clerks. Many judges now aim toward hiring more diverse clerks, marking a significant leap from traditional norms. A necessary step in this direction would be a transformation in their perception of an ideal clerk’s attributes, breaking free from set norms, and valuing skill and potential more. However, the change must be more pervasive, extending to both law schools facilitating clerkships and judges hiring them, for a broader effect.

There is an urgent need for this narrative change. It is time to retire phrases such as ‘good fit’, which veils an antiquated prejudice that limits diversity and inclusivity for legal professions. This shift will help create a fair and more diverse legal profession, benefiting aspiring clerks from historically marginalized groups, reflecting a truer and more equitable representation of society in the legal profession, a realm whose decisions affect us all.