Notable law firm Goodwin began 2023 on a rough note, laying off a number of legal professionals. This was quickly followed by a momentous lateral hiring event, and then by further losses due to “performance review” cuts. An unexpected pattern, though, has been noted: documentation of these layoffs on industry commentary platform Fishbowl are seemingly being deleted without specific reasons cited. Investigation into this peculiar phenomenon reveals an unusual situation concerning the firm’s public image.
Fishbowl caters to insiders who want to share their workplace experiences and insights without heavy filtering. However, posts relating to Goodwin’s layoffs abruptly disappeared, raising questions about the forum’s moderation policies. The vanished posts did not seemingly violate Fishbowl’s community guidelines, which prohibit abusive or threatening content but allow both positive and negative commentary about working conditions. The rules allow moderation for “misinformation,” though the missing posts did not seem to fall under this category either.
In addition, a post mentioning the layoff that included a non-threatening use of the word “damn” also disappeared, suggesting a potentially overactive moderation bot or an unusually strict content monitoring scaling appropriate language use.
Despite these disappearing records, several posts about Goodwin’s layoffs were seen on Fishbowl earlier this week. While the reasons behind these inconsistencies remain unclear, the unusual pattern of post removal has underscored the importance of vigilance in monitoring workplace commentary on online discussion platforms. As for Fishbowl, it will be interesting to see if concrete changes to their moderation practices will follow the spotlight put on their handling of discourse about Goodwin’s layoffs.