The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit declined to block a preliminary injunction this Monday, a decision which enables the US Military Academy in West Point to continue considering race as an admission factor. This news develops as the US Supreme Court is pondering on a similar issue in an appeal presented by Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA).
In a single-page ruling, with the issue pending appeal to the Supreme Court, the court deemed the injunction “unwarranted”. SFFA’s proposed preliminary injunction would have disallowed West Point from considering race while the lawsuit was in progress. Despite achieving no success to date, the group has also brought the lawsuit to the Supreme Court on its emergency docket, requesting that the justices prevent West Point from considering race in the admissions process before the academy’s January 31st application deadline for the graduating class of 2028.
As SFFA wrote in their application for appellate review to the justices, “West Point will label and sort thousands of applicants based on their skin color – including the class of 2028, which West Point will start choosing in earnest once the application deadline closes on January 31”.
Interestingly, SFFA is the same group behind the 2023 Supreme Court ruling that virtually outlawed race in admissions by finding it to be unconstitutional. Since then, this group has sued both West Point and the Naval Academy over their race-based exception, arguing a violation of the Equal Protection Clause within the US Constitution. In the 2023 decision, the Supreme Court declared an effective end to race-based affirmative action at colleges and universities. However, they did not expressly rule on the decision’s application to military service academies.
The SFFA wrote in their application, “Though SFFA appreciates that injunctions are extraordinary, they are necessary when the government refuses to stop facially illegal, rapidly approaching, intentional discrimination,”, acknowledging that the court offers injunctions in rare circumstances.
SFFA has urged the justices to act before the application deadline for West Point. Consequently, the court has ordered West Point to respond by Tuesday.
Find more details in the full article here.