A three-judge panel from the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on Monday overruled a district court decision that blocked a California law requiring individuals seeking to buy ammunition to undergo a background check. The decision allows for the implementation of this law in the state.
The decision by Judges Richard Clifton and Holly Thomas, Bush- and Biden-era appointees respectively, permits the enforcement of long-standing “ammunition laws” while California’s appeal is underway. This comes despite Judge Consuelo Callahan’s dissent against the order, stating a belief that Attorney General Rob Bonta had not demonstrated that the appeal had a high likelihood of success or the potential for “irreparable injury absent the stay.”
The challenge to these laws was brought in the case of Rhode v. Bonta, involving former US Olympian shooter Kim Rhode as a plaintiff. The challengers who successfully obtained an injunction against the law at the district level alleged that these laws violated the Second Amendment of the US Constitution.
District Judge Roger Benitez, known for his previous knockdowns of California gun control statutes, cited the US Supreme Court’s opinion in New York Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. Stating that the checks lacked “historical pedigree,” Benitez argued that the broad reach of these background checks would have never gained acceptance from the county’s “ancestors”.
Following the Bruen, decision, gun laws now need to be “consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.” California’s motion to stay argued that Bruen was misapplied and that background checks are constitutionally endorsed by the Supreme Court.
Amplifying this, California Attorney General Bonta commended the stay, acknowledging that the state had regained a vital tool in battling gun violence.
California and the Ninth Circuit continue to be the primary arenas for an array of gun control laws, from assault weapon bans, public carry regulations, to increased taxation on ammunition for gun violence intervention. The outcomes of many appeals currently pending at the appeal court level linked to these laws are yet to be established.
Further details on this story can be found on Jurist at the following link.