Dutch Court Orders Halt to F-35 Fighter Jet Parts Export to Israel Over International Law Concerns

The Appeals Court in The Hague has ordered the Dutch government to halt the export of F-35 fighter jet parts to Israel, citing concerns that the aircraft are being used by Israel in violation of international laws. This decision overturned an earlier ruling from a lower court.

The court sided with various human rights groups, declaring that there is a considerable risk that F-35 fighter jets could be used in serious violation of international law as a result of Israel’s lax consideration of the consequences of its attacks on civilian populations. Additionally, the court maintained that the Dutch minister’s refusal to revoke the license to export spare parts to Israel indicated the Netherlands’ failure to comply with its international responsibilities. Read the court’s verdict here.

The Dutch Aid Minister, Geoffrey van Leeuwen, has stated the government’s intention to contest the ruling, asserting the Netherlands’ obligation to be a “reliable partner” who fulfills agreements to supply spare aircraft parts to other countries. Legal experts within the government have posed questions over the efficacy of the ruling, arguing that Israel could procure these parts from other sources even if the Netherlands ceases supply.

The lawsuit began in December 2023 when NGOs Oxfam Novib, Peace Movement PAX Netherlands, and The Rights Forum took legal action against the Dutch government, contending that supplying Israel with F-35 parts violated international law and should therefore be suspended. A lower court disagreed, ruling that the transfer of military equipment was within the Minister for Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation’s jurisdiction and that judicial intervention should be minimized in political decisions.

The parts for the F-35 fighter jets, an American-made aircraft, are stored in Woensdrecht, a town in southern Netherlands, before being imported by US allies worldwide, including Israel. The transfer of military equipment requires a permit, which was issued to Israel in 2016.

Humanitarian organizations involved in the case assert that Israeli attacks breach international law due to the excessive number of civilian casualties, which includes children, and the outright destruction of essential infrastructure such as hospitals. Their demands to the court are cordoned on Dutch obligations under the EU Global Strategy (EUGS), the Arms Trade Treaty of 2014, and the Geneva Conventions. These international laws mandate the prevention of military equipment exports in situations where there is a clear risk of significant breaches in humanitarian law.