Personnel documents from two prior law firms are required for Kirkland & Ellis to provide a comprehensive defense in a sexual discrimination case filed by Zoya Kovalenko, a former associate at the firm, according to an attorney representing Kirkland & Ellis.
Attention is being directed at performance review and dismissal reports from Fish & Richardson and Paul Hastings, both former employers of Kovalenko. These documents could provide further detail on potential “specific criticisms” that previous employers may have had with Kovalenko, according to Joseph Liburt, partner at Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe, who is acting as outside counsel for Kirkland.
Thomas Hixson, a judge in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, has yet to issue a decision regarding Kirkland’s request for these documents. A written order is expected to be delivered at a future date.
Kovalenko worked as an intellectual property litigation associate with Kirkland in Northern California for ten months between 2020 and 2021. Allegations in her suit include gender-based discrimination, workload inequality, and pay disparities on the grounds of gender, as the firm reportedly compensated male colleagues at higher rates. She also alleges that she was compelled to work during her anticipated time off, enabling a male associate’s week-long leave to proceed “undisturbed”.
Kovalenko, currently represented by Tanvir Rahman of the employment law firm Filippatos PLLC, asserts that the submission of her former firm’s documents could lead to a “trial within a trial” and open “a big can of worms”.
In their defense, Kirkland managed to establish in court that a sexual harassment claim can also be predicated on formal work actions like personnel management verdicts. The court also concluded that there is potential for a defamation claim under California law, based on the performance reviews received at Kirkland.
Although initially handling her case pro se, Kovalenko now also retains the services of the Los Angeles-based employment law firm, Hennig Kramer Ruiz & Singh.
Kirkland, for its part, has yet to begin deposing witnesses and is presently contemplating a motion to dismiss.
Further details of the case can be found by accessing Kovalenko v. Kirkland & Ellis LLP, N.D. Cal., No. 4:22-cv-05990, initially lodged on October 12, 2022.