Mounting Legal Risks for Companies Making Unverifiable Sustainability Claims

A recent wave of lawsuits underscores the legal risks inherent in making ambitious sustainability claims in corporate environmental and social marketing. Brands like Hershey, United Airlines, and Mondelez International Inc. – the company that has made sustainability claims regarding the cocoa used in its Oreos – are at the forefront of these legal challenges.

Plaintiffs in these consumer suits are asserting that these companies’ promises regarding eco-friendly practices and ethically sourced goods are largely unverifiable and potentially misleading. The objective of these legal actions is to hold companies accountable for their statements that assert environmental sustainability and ethical sourcing commitments. Plaintiffs argue that these claims are deceitful to consumers who are increasingly aware and concerned of their impact on the environment.

Skeptics, backed by these recent lawsuits, are questioning the extent to which corporate claims of “100% sustainable” practices can be substantiated. In fact, within the last month, there have been two significant lawsuits directed at the food and beverage industry. Consumers have sued Mondelez International Inc. and The Hershey Co. for their marketing assertions relating to the cocoa used in Oreos, as well as in organic and plant-based chocolate bars.

In response to these lawsuits, corporations may find themselves obligated to provide evidence that backs up their assertive sustainability claims, to ensure they are not misleading consumers. If found noncompliant, these companies could face substantial fines and reputational damage – a costly consequence in today’s environmentally conscious consumer marketplace, where ‘sustainability’ is often a deciding factor influencing purchasing decisions.

It can therefore be seen that despite the appeal of such marketing messages, particularly given the growing general interest in sustainability, companies must be careful to ensure their environmental and social claims are fully substantiated.

For more details, click on the following link to read the full article here.