Elected Female Leadership in Environmental Law Faces Controversial Commentary

In a recent turn of events at the Philadelphia Bar Association, the election of new leadership for its Environmental and Energy Law committees stirred controversy on LinkedIn. The newly elected co-chairs and vice-chair, all female, were congratulated in a post that typically wouldn’t draw much attention against the ever-busy backdrop of this professional networking platform Above the Law reported.

However, this changed when Larry Schnapf, an environmental lawyer and adjunct at NYU, added his controversial comment to the thread. Schnapf cheekily asked about the representation of men in the newly elected leadership. While it is possible that Schnapf was protesting “reverse discrimination”, we could also give him the benefit of the doubt and consider this comment to be a quip intended for ironic humour.

This transpired despite the explicit progress made in gender representation in the United States, where an all-female team might not even raise eyebrows in some circles. The situation also unintentionally underscored the achievements of the elected officials, all women, thus subtly highlighting strides made in gender parity.

Schnapf, being well-versed in the environmental law professional scene, might have thought his comment to be a satirical reflection – intended to make his professional contacts chuckle in agreement. But the absence of context and the nature of LinkedIn, where comments are not typically limited to known circles, can make such satire tricky ground.

Examples like New York Times Pitchbot or Three Year Letterman who have crafted an online reputation for satire can navigate such complexities, but it’s tougher for a professional posting under his real name to make such ironic statements without them being misunderstood. Therefore, it’s crucial for online users, especially in professional settings, to understand and respect the boundaries and limitations tied to online platforms. Not all humour translates well across all mediums.