New York Appeals Court Denies Standing for Judges Suing Judicial Screening Panels

The legal world has seen a decisive ruling regarding lawsuits against judicial panels by lawyers in their assessments. Former Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Laura Lee Jacobson attempted to bring a breach-of-contract lawsuit against a local judicial screening panel. The panel had reviewed her re-election application and declared her ‘not qualified’ for the role. Jacobson alleged the committee had unlawfully made public information concerning its decision. A crucial part of the suit rested on the claim that this was in violation of its own rules, after the judge had withdrawn from panel review. However, she has been thwarted by a latest verdict from a New York appeals court.

The four New York Supreme Court First Appellate Department judges explained in the ruling that Jacobson is not a member of the committee. Therefore, they concluded, she “does not have standing to enforce defendants’ internal rules.” This decision to deny Jacobson legal standing appears to be a significant moment for inherent power relations in legal assessments. Furthermore, the lower court was affirmed in its proper dismissal of Jacobson’s defamation claims in relation to the issue.

In light of this recent ruling, the legal professionals may want to rethink their interactions with judicial panels and the strategy to tackle unfavorable qualifications hereafter.