The principles and values instituted by the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg continue to shake the legal world, even posthumously. Her legacy was fortified in 2019 when the Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg Leadership Award was established in her honor. The award, envisioned by RBG and the Opperman Foundation, was designed to commemorate “women who exemplify human qualities of empathy and humility.”
However, eyebrows have shot up concerning the integrity of the award following some controversial decisions by the Opperman Foundation. The foundation’s selected recipients for this year’s award appear to be in stark contrast with Ginsburg’s expectations. James S. Ginsburg, her son, noted the awardees as an “insult to her name and legacy.”
More details on the contentious nominees can be gleaned from the New York Times and included the likes of Elon Musk, Rupert Murdoch, and Michael Milken. These four male recipients were selected, despite the award’s initial design to honor women. Furthermore, their collective reputation raises questions about their embodiment of the qualities of empathy and humility associated with the award.
In response to the backlash, the Opperman Foundation justified their selection, stating that they are promoting potential honorees from all genders since “Justice Ginsburg fought not only for women but for everyone.” But critics argue that this explanation fails to address the incongruent match between the awardees’ public personas and Ginsburg’s values.
The inclination of the foundation’s chairwoman, Julie Opperman, may shed some light on the surprising recipients, as a
report by Mother Jones revealed that she is a significant GOP donor.
To contest such circumstances, RBG’s former clerk and ex-dean of NYU Law School, Trevor W. Morrison, addressed a letter to the foundation criticizing the nomination. Columbia Law professor and Ginsburg’s daughter, Jane Ginsburg, added her voice, stating that the Ginsburg family did not endorse the choice of awardees.
Given this current debacle, Ginsburg’s children have urged the foundation to remove their mother’s title from the award, unless it reverts to the original criteria outlined by the late justice. The unfolding situation sheds light on the potential manipulation of institutional awards, underscoring the need for vigilance in safeguarding the original vision and values upon which such honors are founded.