President Joe Biden’s recent executive order aimed at limiting the transfer of sensitive US personal data finally addresses a previously exposed gap in US regulation on sensitive personal data. Before the order, foreign investors who wished to invest in US companies holding sensitive data could face restrictions via the CFIUS process. However, if the same foreign actors wanted to purchase the same sensitive data without making an investment, there was no mechanism at hand for the government to intervene. The proposed rule now restricts general sharing of bulk sensitive personal data of US persons.
Companies that could potentially be affected by the soon-to-be-implemented regulations can participate by submitting their comments, assessing risk profiles and modifying compliance programs ahead of the yet to be finalized rule. Over the past few years, US national security officials have voiced increasing concern about the inherent threats related to the sale of sensitive personal data to foreign entities. In 2018, a study noted a fitness app revealing outlines of sensitive US military bases via user geolocation data. Media reports have echoed the ease with which sensitive data sets, including military personnel health and financial metrics, can be acquired from “data brokers”.
Theexecutive order issued on February 28 instructs the Department of Justice to undertake a rulemaking process with notice and comment. The initial step, anadvanced notice of proposed rulemaking by the DOJ, has been issued. The proposed rule seeks to prohibit certain types of transactions and impose security-related restrictions on other transactions via a new regulatory mechanism.
First, it’s essential to understand that the proposed rule covers a wide array of transactions pertaining to sensitive data. The DOJ defines ‘bulk sensitive US personal data’ to include various ‘personal identifiers’ linked to a US person’s digital identity, in addition to geolocation data, personal health, financial data, and several other data types.
Secondly, the rule extensively defines who will be impacted, encompassing any company/national residing in China (including Hong Kong and Macau), Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba or Venezuela. Any entity owned 50% by such a company or national would also fall under the rule’s enforcement, consequently bringing some overseas subsidiaries or investment funds based in Europe, the Middle East, etc., under the scope of the rule. It is still unclear if US subsidiaries of Chinese companies would be classified as covered entities.
The forthcoming rule essentially prohibits ‘covered persons’ from accessing bulk sensitive US data, whether it’s through a sale, license, or subscription. While this rule automatically impacts data brokers, it may also affect US companies that don’t typically consider themselves as data businesses. For instance, an American company sharing customer information with a Chinese company as part of a partnership could potentially be affected by this prohibition.
The new rule will also regulate investment agreements, employment agreements, and vendor agreements with these covered entities, necessitating adherence to the security requirements laid down by the Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Even though these requirements have not been officially released yet, it can be expected that they will necessitate physical and cybersecurity requirements to prevent the violation of accessing sensitive bulk data.
It is of paramount importance for concerned companies to prepare adequately in light of the forthcoming order. The proposed rule’s potentially extensive scope may encourage companies to participate in the regulatory process by submitting individual comments or through trade associations. These will be accepted until April 19. As suggested by a senior DOJ official, multinational companies should proactively develop their ‘risk-based compliance programs’ based on individualized risk profiles by scrutinizing the possessed data, those privy to that data, and the existing agreements granting access to it.
Businesses are also urged to anticipate any potential secondary effects. In some cases, Chinese competitors seeking to solidify their presence in the US market could be constrained to industries where data impacted by the proposed rules would be less prevalent. It could impact market dynamics in pivotal sectors like healthcare, defense, telecommunications, and other vital industries.
Despite the numerous regulations already present, it is observed that presidents, in the last one and a half decades, have been invoking national security to develop new regulatory frameworks, and more regulatory systems are springing up, including theproposed ‘outbound investment’ regulations and recently released information and communications technology and servicesregulations. It can be anticipated that this pattern of extending national security regulation by executive action will continue in the future. Based on the information released so far, it is expected that the final rule will have noteworthy implications for many US companies, impacting business operations and subsequent compliance programs.