The State of Georgia’s Parole Board has
denied
clemency for inmate Willie James Pye, positioned the state for its first execution since 2020. Pye was
convicted
and sentenced to death in 1996 for the murder of Alicia Lynn Yarbough, his then-girlfriend.
Arguments for clemency were based on Pye’s intellectual disability and troubled childhood, an approach his lawyers further substantiated in a
court filing in 2021.
They argued executing a person with an intellectual disability contravenes the
Eighth Amendment
, which aims to safeguard citizens from governmental harm. Referencing the US Supreme Court case
Atkins v. Virginia,
execution of intellectually disabled persons is deemed “cruel and unusual punishment,” and thus a violation of the Eighth Amendment.
In addition to Pye’s defense, Johnny Mostiler, his court-appointed trial attorney, was
accused of providing ineffective representation and exhibiting racial bias in cases involving black defendants. He allegedly spent limited hours on Pye’s case where such defence typically necessitates thousands of hours. Nevertheless, a court ruling in 2021 overturned Pye’s death sentence based on Mostiler’s failure to consider all available evidence. Subsequently, following a state’s motion, the court reinstated the death sentence, asserting Mostiler’s performance should be deferred to the state under the
Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act.
Set for March 20, Pye’s execution will mark the first after more than four years at the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson, using lethal injection to administer a sedative, pentobarbital.
The last execution held by the state of Georgia occurred in 2020, when Donnie Cleveland Lance, who was
convicted
for murder, was executed by lethal injection. With COVID-19 affecting proceedings in 2021, attorneys agreed to
suspend
certain prisoner executions temporarily.