Fifth Circuit Court Upholds Graphic Warning Requirements on Cigarette Packaging

On Thursday, a three-judge panel on the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit dismissed a First Amendment based challenge brought by tobacco companies against a bill that mandates graphic imagery on cigarette packaging and advertisements. The companies had claimed that the requirement violated the First Amendment of the United States Constitution.

The bill in question is the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (TCA), which was enacted by Congress in 2009. The TCA compels cigarette packaging to include color graphics portraying the negative health consequences of smoking. These depictions must cover the top 50 percent of the front and rear panels of a package and comprise at least 20 percent of any advertisement.

The law had previously been challenged as unconstitutional by tobacco companies and was upheld by the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in 2012. After this setback, the tobacco companies contested the FDA’s implementation of the regulations, leading to this recent case.

In this case, the plaintiffs alleged that the FDA’s interpretation of the TCA was in breach of First Amendment principles of freedom of speech. They argued that they were being forced to include warnings that exaggerate or misrepresent the potential effects of smoking. However, Judge Jerry Smith ruled that although these warnings constituted compelled speech, they were factual and uncontroversial in nature.

The court also held that these warnings, which included unsettling imagery such as diseased lungs, surgical scars, and amputations, were justified by a legitimate state interest and did not place an undue strain on the plaintiffs. Arguments that the graphic depictions were not factual were dismissed, with the court asserting that they were not dissimilar to those found in a medical student’s textbook.

Whilst the panel rejected the First Amendment argument, they did uphold the plaintiffs’ argument that the regulations may have violated the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), a law governing how regulations are established.

This lawsuit is the latest high-profile matter involving government-compelled speech in the business sector, following a recent case in Maryland regarding the provision of suicide prevention literature in gun stores.