The Anheuser-Busch InBev SA/NV unit responsible for Corona beer production has lost its appeal in the Second Circuit of the United States Court of Appeals. The appeal contested a lower-court ruling that disapproved of blocking its US distributor, Constellation Brands Inc., from retailing hard seltzer under the brand’s name. The judicial panel deemed the meaning of ‘beer’ in its license from ABI’s Cerveceria Modelo de Mexico, extending to hard cider, as ambiguous, consequently denoting a jury decision rather than a court injunction.
Moreover, the Second Circuit found no error in the judgment of the jury instructions, thereby dismissing Modelo’s appeal for revision in them. As per the ruling, hard seltzer sales under the Corona brand will proceed in the United States.
Modelo had earlier declared that the US distributor had surpassed its license limit. However, the court found the distributor free of any such malpractice, thereby overruling Modelo’s claim. With the appeal failing to garner support from the Second Circuit, Modelo has to reconsider its strategies keeping in mind the broader and more flexible interpretation of ‘beer’.
This ruling carries significant implications for the global beer industry, given the burgeoning popularity of hard seltzers and their subsequent impact on traditional beer sales. Legal professionals within corporate conglomerates and law firms, especially those associated with the consumables sector, should be apprised of such developments, as they may permeate their legal tactics in the future.