In a surprise court decision, a Texas judge has transferred an industry challenge to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB) credit card late fee rule to Washington, D.C, potentially impacting a popular legal strategy. The US Chamber of Commerce, the American Bankers Association, and the Consumer Bankers Association, along with several Texas industry groups, raced to ask the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas on March 7 to block the CFPB’s late fee rule.
The plan to quickly file a lawsuit in a business-friendly Texas courthouse is a familiar strategy, but industry groups didn’t anticipate Judge Mark Pittman’s decision to move the case to Washington, D.C., where the CFPB is headquartered. As a result, banking and other industries may require to rethink their propensity for filing in Texas.
The final CFBP rule proposes to cap credit card late fees at $8, a significant drop from the current limit of $30 for the first missed payment and $41 for further missed payments over the subsequent six months. Industry groups argue the CFPB overstepped its bounds in creating the rule, which is slated to go into effect May 14, and are attempting to pause or revoke it.
The case was moved because none of the banks affected by the rule are based in the Northern District of Texas. One of the plaintiffs, Synchrony Bank, joined the Fort Worth Chamber of Commerce in an effort to establish standing but the CFPB argued that this wasn’t sufficient. Judge Pittman sided with CFPB.
Despite the unexpected venue change, the fate of the late fee rule remains uncertain. The Chamber and its co-plaintiffs appealed Pittman’s denial of their preliminary injunction request to the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on March 25. The court suspended the transfer until the end of business on Tuesday, March 30, saying it would expedite hearing the case.
Meanwhile, the remanded case has been assigned to Judge Amy Berman Jackson in the US District Court for the District of Columbia. Depending on the outcome of a pending Supreme Court case regarding CFPB’s funding, Judge Jackson may choose to pause the rule.
The unexpected industry setback may have implications beyond the late fee rule, particularly concerning the controversial practice known as ‘judge shopping’. Concern over this practice extends to The Judiciary Council and Justice Neil Gorsuch, who reacted during oral arguments in a case related to the Food and Drug Administration’s approval of abortion medication last month.
The case information is US Chamber of Commerce v. CFPB, N.D. Tex., No. 4:24-cv-00213 and US Chamber of Commerce v. CFPB, D.D.C., No. 1:24-cv-00915, as recorded on March 28 and March 29, respectively.
You can read more on Bloomberg Law.