Costco Succeeds in Disqualifying Law Firm over Ex-Counsel Connection

In an interesting turn of events, Costco Wholesale Corp has managed to get a California law firm disqualified from representing a plaintiff who was seeking to hold the corporation responsible for a slip-and-fall accident. This comes after the court confirmed the firm’s association with ex-Costco counsel.

The issue boils down to the role of Anthony Werbin, an attorney with Downtown LA Law Group. Though he was not the plaintiff’s counsel of record, he had a notable history with Costco, previously serving as the retailer’s lead counsel in 21 cases.

Where the issue began to emerge is related to the law firm’s failure to prove that it had safeguarded against the potential risk of information leakage between Werbin, a former insider, and the rest of the firm. Essentially, the firm did not provide sufficient evidence that it had secured measures in place to protect confidential information related to Costco cases from being shared with Werbin and other attorneys in the firm.

This order by the US District Court for the Southern District of California takes a step further into outlining reasons for disqualification. As a result, Downtown LA Law finds itself disqualified from multiple Costco cases.

This decision highlights the ever-important issue of client-attorney confidentiality and is sure to spark conversation among law firms and large corporations alike with respect to their selection and interaction with legal counsel.