Wisconsin State Bar Amends Diversity Definition in Clerkship Program Amid Lawsuit

In the midst of a legal battle, the Wisconsin State Bar, which has been fending off a lawsuit concerning its diversity clerkship program, made amendments to the program’s definition of diversity to exclude any reference to race. Aiming to address the implications of part of the original litigation, these language changes led to the withdrawal of a segment of the lawsuit, according to an announcement made by the Bar on Thursday.

There has been a lawsuit against the Wisconsin State Bar since December 2023, filed by attorney Daniel Suhr in the U.S. District Court in Eastern Wisconsin. Suhr is represented by the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL). He alleges that the Bar’s diversity program is unconstitutional, claiming a violation of his First Amendment rights related to his compulsory attorney fees being used to fund the program against his wishes.

State Bar Executive Director Larry J. Martin maintains that while the definition of ‘diversity’ has been clarified, there have not been any changes made to the program itself. He affirmed that the Diversity Clerkship Program, which has been providing opportunities to law students in Wisconsin for over thirty years, will retain its current form.

The new definition of diversity is now stated to mean the inclusion of individuals with differing characteristics, beliefs, experiences, interests, and viewpoints. This definition stresses upon the respectful treatment of individuals, without adhering to stereotypes, promoting a better understanding of the needs and perspectives of those that we interact.

However, the lawsuit is not fully resolved. Suhr’s claims that his free speech and First Amendment rights were violated are yet to be addressed. The assertion stems from the Bar using obligatory member fees for expenditures he deemed “non-germane” a point that WILL continues to bring forth in court.

The fight, per WILL litigator Skylar Croy’s statement, is far from over. He expressed optimism about the victory but added that it was merely the initial step of a burgeoning movement. He believes their lawsuit will delineate a strategy for successive victories all across the 50 states. The case is Suhr v. Dietrich et al, E.D. Wis., No. 2:23-cv-01697.