Social Media Platform X Fights Australian Order to Remove Sydney Church Attack Posts Globally

Social media platform X, previously known as Twitter, has publicly declared its intention to legally challenge an order from the Australian eSafety Commissioner. The order demanded the removal of specific posts relating to a recent violent attack on a Christian Bishop in Sydney. The company stated that it had received a command from the eSafety Commissioner to remove applicable posts worldwide or be penalised with a daily fine of AUD 785,000 (approx. $500,000 USD).

While the company agreed to comply with the direction temporarily until a legal challenge can be progressed, X maintains that the posts in question did not breach the platform’s internal rules and policies on violent speech. X’s disagreement with the order is rooted in its belief that the eSafety Commissioner lacks the authority to determine what information users can access globally.

In April, significant violent incidents in Sydney, including Bishop Marmari of the Assyrian Church being attacked during a service by a 16-year-old boy, prompted concerns. The eSafety Commissioner requested social media platforms remove any violent or distressing images relating to such events.

Mentioned Commissioner Julie Inman Grant, feeling the need to utilise the powers granted to her by the 2021 Online Safety Act, went a step further to formally compel the platforms to eliminate all associated posts.

This triggered a legal move from the eSafety Commissioner to obtain a temporary injunction against X. As a catalyst for this motion, it was argued that X merely ‘geo-blocked’ the contentious content, enabling it still to be accessible outside Australia using a VPN. This action was deemed insufficient under the boundaries of the Online Safety Act.

X’s refusal to fully comply also faced criticism from Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who expressed in a press conference his disbelief at X’s approach and emphasised social media’s obligation to act responsibly.

The current legal status has been temporarily settled by Justice Geoffrey Kennett, who mandated the contentious content to be flagged with a global notice until a final court decision is made.

For full details of these developments, the original reporting can be found here.