In the world of copyright disputes, the timing of discovery regarding infringement often sparks discussion. The Federal Copyright Act requires a claim to be brought within three years of its origination. A self-created “discovery rule” enables plaintiffs to seek compensation within three years of the alleged infringement, irrespective of when it occurred.
Warner Chappell Music, Inc. v. Nealy, held on May 9 by the US Supreme Court, did not address the question of whether the discovery rule pertains in instances of copyright infringement. The court also sidestepped a case that would have tackled the issue on May 20, Hearst Newspapers LLC v. Martinelli.
Nevertheless, the Warner Chappell case did settle the matter of copyright damages and their accrual period. Contrarily, a 2020 Second Circuit Appeals Court ruling, Sohm v. Scholastic, Inc., claimed that copyright action plaintiffs can only recuperate damages as far back as three years from their complaint. This places difficulties on discovering infringements that took place years ahead of the revelation.
The case centers around Sherman Nealy, an independent music producer who has accused Warner Chappell Music and Artist Publishing Group of owing him royalties for the use of his songs. His allegations stem from the claim that the music licenses were agreed upon without his knowledge while he was in prison.
The recent Supreme Court decision has provided legal practitioners and litigants some guidance. Once the infringement is proven and the discovery rule is satisfied, there will be no time restriction on monetary recovery. Yet, the question whether a claim should be initiated within three years of discovering the infringement still remains unanswered.
The legal tussle between Nealy and Warner Chappell continues unabated— the case has been referred back for further deliberation. It is highly possible that this dispute, or a similar one, may return to the Supreme Court, as the issue of the three-year cap from infringement or discovery persists.
Full case details can be found here.
Thomas W. Brooke, a partner in the intellectual property practice at Holland & Knight in Washington, is the author of the original Bloomberg Law report.