ECHR Rules Hungary’s Ban on Medically Assisted Death does not Violate Human Rights


The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) recently ruled that Hungarian authorities’ refusal to permit a medically assisted death for a terminally ill citizen does not contravene the European Convention on Human Rights. The case, filed by Daniel Karsai, arose from his request for access to medical suicide following a diagnosis of motor neurone disease, an incurable condition leading to the gradual loss of voluntary muscle control, including respiratory muscles, typically resulting in death within three to five years due to respiratory failure.

Hungarian law criminalizes aiding someone to end their life, and anyone assisting in such acts domestically or abroad may face prosecution. Karsai claimed that Hungary’s refusal discriminated against him under Article 14 and Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, contrasting his situation with that of terminally ill patients who have the right to refuse life-sustaining treatments under Hungarian law.

The ECHR’s decision emphasized the broad discretion national authorities possess in determining the legality of physician-assisted death. The court noted that Hungary’s legal prohibition against medical suicide was balanced against potential social implications and risks of misuse. Hungarian authorities had, according to the court, adequately balanced Karsai’s wishes against the legitimate aims of prohibiting such procedures.

In its judgement, the court also pointed out that Karsai rejected palliative care options, which comply with the European Association of Palliative Care‘s recommendations and could relieve suffering for patients in similar conditions. The court asserted that personal preference to forgo available palliative care does not obligate authorities to provide or legalize other medically assisted alternatives.

Regarding Article 14, the court found no discrimination. There is a distinction between the right to refuse medical treatment, which is embedded in the principle of informed consent, and the right to assisted suicide, which is not recognized by the EU. This justified the disparate treatment between Karsai and other terminally ill patients.

Moreover, the ECHR highlighted that although some European countries are moving towards legalizing medical suicide, many states still prohibit both euthanasia and medically assisted suicide. The court reaffirmed that the European Convention should be interpreted in light of contemporary societal and ethical standards.

For further details, the full article can be accessed here.