Supreme Court Confirms DOJ’s Immunity from Refunding $326 Million in Bankruptcy Fees



The Supreme Court has ruled that the Department of Justice (DOJ) is not required to refund approximately $326 million in fees collected from Chapter 11 debtors during a period when Congress inadvertently created a fee discrepancy. This decision addresses a lingering question from 2022 when the Court ruled that the fee disparity was unconstitutional.

The fee discrepancy arose when Congress increased the maximum fee the DOJ’s bankruptcy watchdog, the US Trustee, could collect starting in 2018. However, this increase did not apply to bankruptcies in Alabama and North Carolina, creating an uneven financial burden on Chapter 11 debtors depending on their jurisdiction. During oral arguments, the justices acknowledged that there was no ideal remedy for the issue at hand.

The ruling provides clarity on the controversial issue of fee discrepancies in bankruptcy cases, signaling a conclusion to a problem that has troubled the courts since its discovery. To read more about the 2022 ruling, refer to this Bloomberg Law article.

  • Supreme Court addresses remedy issue it had left open in 2022
  • Justices said during argument there wasn’t an ideal solution

For further details on the Supreme Court’s decision about the DOJ’s exemption from refunding the bankruptcy fees, visit Bloomberg Law.