European Court of Human Rights Declares Russia’s “Undesirable Organization” Law in Breach of Freedom Conventions

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ruled that Russia’s “undesirable organization” law is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), to which Russia was a signatory until 2022. The case, Andrey Rylkov Foundation and Others v. Russia, saw the Strasbourg court unanimously determine that the law violated Article 10 (freedom of expression) and Article 11 (freedom of assembly and association) of the ECHR.

The applicants included four organizations previously declared “undesirable” by Russian authorities: the Free Russia Foundation (US-based), the Ukrainian World Congress (Toronto-based), the Association of Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe (Strasbourg-based), and Společnost Svobody Informace (Prague-based). Furthermore, three Russian organizations and several Russian nationals were also involved, having been convicted for their association with “undesirable” organizations.

In its ruling, the ECtHR held that the 2015 law lacked the necessary precision to forewarn organizations that their lawful actions could result in an “undesirable” designation, effectively prohibiting their activities in Russia. Notably, the court found the law suffered from a lack of adequate safeguards against arbitrary enforcement and granted unrestricted discretion to Russian authorities. These deficiencies meant the law did not meet the ECHR’s requirement for prescribed legal interference with Convention rights.

Russia is obligated under the doctrine of just satisfaction to compensate the applicants for non-pecuniary damages, as well as legal costs and expenses. Despite Russia’s departure from the Council of Europe, it remains bound to comply with this binding judgment, as required by Article 46 of the Convention. The ECtHR’s Committee of Ministers will scrutinize the enforcement of the court’s judgments, compelling Russia to implement Tuesday’s decision.

The “undesirable organization” law, introduced in May 2015, followed the 2012 Foreign Agent law and the Dima Yakovlev law, and enabled Russian officials to extrajudicially declare foreign and international organizations “undesirable.” Such a designation could severely restrict an organization’s operations in Russia, including bans on having offices or bank registrations, and could lead to harsh penalties if ignored.

Critics have long branded the legislation as arbitrary and vague. Upon its promulgation in 2015, Amnesty International described it as a troubling mechanism to stifle dissent, arguing it would further limit public space for criticism. The recent ECtHR ruling underscores these concerns, marking a significant critique of Russia’s regulatory framework for civil society organizations.

For additional details on the Court’s decision, visit JURIST’s comprehensive coverage.