The Supreme Court has selected five new cases to examine in its 2024-25 term, emerging from their recent clean-up conference. Two of these cases will be argued together. The justices have chosen not to review several high-profile challenges, such as disputes over Illinois’ assault weapons regulations and the powers of federal agencies, including the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA).
One notable case, Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, questions a Texas law that mandates age verification for websites with content deemed “harmful to minors.” The challengers argue this burdens adult access, but the Fifth Circuit upheld the law under rational basis review. The Supreme Court will decide if strict scrutiny should be the applicable standard instead.
Another pair of cases, Hewitt v. United States and Duffey v. United States, concerns the First Step Act. The primary issue is whether sentence reductions from the Act apply to defendants originally sentenced before the Act’s enactment but resentenced afterward.
In Monsalvo Velazquez v. Garland, the court will address if noncitizens can avoid penalties for failing to leave the country by filing a motion to reopen immigration proceedings on the next business day when their deadline falls on a weekend or holiday.
The court will also review Food and Drug Administration v. Wages and White Lion Investments LLC, a Biden administration petition regarding a Fifth Circuit ruling that challenged the FDA’s denial of e-cigarette marketing applications.
Additionally, the court rejected multiple cases accompanied by separate writings from the justices. Notably, Justice Clarence Thomas criticized the denial to hear a case on Illinois’ gun laws but acceded, noting that the matter was still in the preliminary stages. Justice Sonia Sotomayor issued a 13-page statement agreeing with the denial of another case involving outdated forensic evidence, suggesting legislative action is warranted despite the court’s decision.
Further details and the complete list of orders from the justices’ private conference can be found here.
This information was adapted from a report initially published at SCOTUSblog.