The European Committee of Social Rights (ECSR) has found that Spain’s labor legislation falls short of the standards set by the Revised European Social Charter. The Committee’s decision arose from a collective complaint filed by the Unión General de Trabajadores (UGT), identified as Complaint No. 207/2022. The UGT contended that Spain’s compensation mechanisms for unfair dismissal are insufficient to cover the damage suffered by dismissed workers.
In its decision on March 28, 2024, the ECSR concluded by 13 votes to 1 that Spanish law violates Article 24.b of the Social Charter, which guarantees adequate compensation for workers terminated without just cause. The Committee noted that the stipulated compensation amounts were insufficient and that any limits preventing proportional harm compensation are inconsistent with the Social Charter.
The European Social Charter is a treaty formulated by the Council of Europe, initially signed in 1961 and later revised in 1996. This comprehensive treaty safeguards various human rights, including those related to employment. Spain ratified the original Charter in 1980 and approved the Revised Charter in 2021, further ratifying the Additional Protocol Providing for a System of Collective Complaints in 2022.
Spain’s domestic labor regulations derive from several national statutes, including Labor Statute No. 2/2015, Law Governing Social Jurisdiction No. 36/2011, and Civil Code No. 206/1889. These laws dictate the conditions under which an employee may demand termination of a contract and establish the consequences for unfair or illegal dismissals, including potential reinstatement or compensation.
Despite these regulations, judicial practices have shown variability in compensation awards, depending on specific case circumstances. This latest ruling underscores the necessity for Spain to align its labor laws with the Revised European Social Charter’s requirements, focusing particularly on enhancing the robustness of mechanisms providing fair compensation for unjust dismissals.
For the full report, visit JURIST.