Household Brands Push to Redefine ‘Recyclable’ Amid Sustainability Concerns

Most plastic products found in kitchens today, such as the film lids on Dole Sunshine fruit bowls and the straws attached to Juicy Juice boxes, are difficult to recycle. Despite this, a trade group representing these and other major brands is lobbying for a redefinition of the term ‘recyclable’, a move that experts say could exacerbate the global plastic pollution crisis.

The Consumer Brands Association proposes that products should be labeled ‘recyclable’ if they are technically capable of being recycled, regardless of the likelihood of them actually being recycled. This push coincides with the Federal Trade Commission’s revision of the Green Guides—guidelines that govern how products can be marketed as sustainable.

The association’s board includes officials from companies such as PepsiCo, Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, and Campbell Soup. Notably, some of these companies own brands that promote health and sustainability, like General Mills’ Annie’s macaroni and cheese and The Honest Co. Despite this sustainable image, none of the 51 companies contacted by ProPublica for comment expressed disagreement with the proposed change. Nine companies referred back to the association.

Joseph Aquilina, the association’s vice president and deputy general counsel, stated in an email that the industry is committed to creating a circular economy and has invested in sustainability goals and consumer education tools, including detailed recycling instructions. However, the broader implications of redefining ‘recyclable’ are contentious.

Federally issued Green Guides currently permit the ‘recyclable’ label if 60 percent of Americans have access to recycling facilities for that material. These guidelines do not, however, assure that the materials collected will be effectively recycled into new products.

The reality is that only a fraction of plastic waste—about 5 percent in the U.S.—is recycled. Most of it ends up in landfills or oceans, posing long-term environmental risks. Advanced recycling technologies, though promising, remain limited in scale and effectiveness.