In a case highlighting the complexities of artificial intelligence usage in academia, a school district in Massachusetts is facing legal action after a student was allegedly penalized for using an AI chatbot for an assignment. The parents of the student claim in the lawsuit that the Hingham High School student handbook lacks specific restrictions regarding the use of AI tools.
Jennifer Harris, the student’s mother, told WCVB, “They told us our son cheated on a paper, which is not what happened. They basically punished him for a rule that doesn’t exist.” The lawsuit, initially filed in Plymouth County Superior Court and later moved to the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, names several defendants including the school superintendent, principal, a teacher, the history department head, and the Hingham School Committee.
The student in question, referred to as RNH, is alleged to have violated civil rights, which include rights to equal educational opportunity. Meanwhile, school officials argue in their motion to dismiss that RNH admitted to using an AI tool for generating ideas, as well as parts of his notes and scripts. The school contends that this usage, without citing the AI, constitutes a violation under their existing policy against the unauthorized use of technology and plagiarism.
The handbook defines plagiarism as “unauthorized use or close imitation of the language and thoughts of another author and the representation of them as one’s own work.” Though AI is not specifically mentioned, the school asserts that using AI tools falls under this category.