The Competition Commission of India (CCI) has imposed a penalty of ₹213.14 crore (approximately USD 25.4 million) on Meta Platforms, citing abuse of market dominance through WhatsApp’s 2021 privacy policy update. The CCI determined that the update imposed “unfair conditions” by mandating that users share data across Meta’s applications, a move that contravenes the Competition Act. The policy, launched on a “take-it-or-leave-it” basis, significantly expanded data collection and sharing, removing user autonomy in opting out, and potentially creating barriers for competitors in the online advertising space.
The CCI has further ordered Meta and WhatsApp to halt the sharing of user data for advertising within Meta companies for five years. It also directed WhatsApp to provide clear details on the categories and purposes of data shared, ensuring users can opt out for non-WhatsApp related services. These measures aim to mitigate competition concerns and improve user choice according to CCI’s directive.
In January 2021, the introduction of the updated privacy policy prompted backlash, as users were faced with conditions that disallowed opting out of data sharing – unlike previous policies. This led to an exodus of users to other platforms like Signal and Telegram. Legal challenges ensued, with the Delhi High Court upholding CCI’s right to investigate due to WhatsApp’s dominant market position as reported.
Meta has announced plans to appeal the CCI ruling, asserting that the update was intended to introduce optional business features and enhance data usage transparency without affecting users’ accessibility to WhatsApp. However, the CCI argued that the policy fortifies Meta’s position in the online advertising space by leveraging WhatsApp’s dominance in the OTT messaging market, thereby impairing competition as noted here and reiterated in the appeal announcement.
For further details on this legal development, visit JURIST – News.