Court Overturns Unilateral Arbitration Clause, Affirming Fairness in Contract Law

A recent ruling from the Appellate Division has overturned a controversial one-sided alternative dispute resolution (ADR) provision found in a contract drafted by A&S. The case raised eyebrows due to the clause that permitted A&S to bypass arbitration for its own benefit, particularly to pursue claims for monetary damages directly in court, while obligating the other party to arbitrate any disputes. The decision calls into question the fairness and enforceability of such unilateral contract terms.

The judge noted, “It is apparent A&S drafted the contract and created an exception to arbitration only for itself the power to pursue a claim for money damages—and potentially other claims—in court.” The ruling underscores the balance that courts aim to maintain between the contractual freedom of parties and the imposition of unconscionable terms.

For a deeper dive into the implications of this decision, explore further details on the original article.