Illinois Judge Strikes Down Part of Health Care Law Mandating Speech; First Amendment at Core of Decision

A federal judge in Illinois has delivered a split verdict concerning the Health Care Right of Conscious Act, a contentious state law mandating that health care providers inform patients of the risks and benefits associated with childbirth and abortion. Issued last week by U.S. District Court Judge Iain D. Johnston, the decision scrutinizes parts of the law that some claim infringe on First Amendment rights. Specifically, the judge ruled that a section compelling speech is unconstitutional. The law, enacted in 2016, has faced opposition from several quarters, including the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates and multiple pregnancy centers, which argue that it forces anti-abortion proponents to communicate contrary views. For additional details, visit the full decision on Law.com.