Defining “The People”: Navigating the Complex Interpretations of the Second Amendment

The debate over the interpretation of the Second Amendment remains a contentious legal issue, particularly when it comes to defining “the people” who are granted the right to keep and bear arms. The Second Amendment itself uses the term “the people,” but understanding who exactly this includes can be complex. This discussion is underscored by significant court cases and legal interpretations that have tried to delineate its scope.

  1. The Language of “The People”: The Second Amendment refers to “the people,” and the 2008 landmark decision in District of Columbia v. Heller recognized it as a personal right to possess a firearm for self-defense within the home. The majority opinion in Heller interprets “the people” as all members of the political community. This aligns with Justice Kennedy’s opinion in the 1990 United States v. Verdugo-Urquidez case, which stipulated that “the people” referred to those who have developed sufficient connection with the United States.

  2. Sub-Categories within “The People”: Post-Heller, the exact makeup of “the political community” remains partially defined. Courts have grappled with the inclusion of felons, minors, and noncitizens.

    • Felons: Federal law prevents felons from possessing firearms, contending they lose their standing in the political community due to their crimes. However, courts have exhibited inconsistency on this matter. For example, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit in the 2024 Garland v. Range case rejected the notion that felons could be excluded from the people.
    • Minors: Judicial interpretations, such as those in Worth v. Jacobson and Rocky Mountain Gun Owners v. Polis, have found that 18- to 20-year-olds should be considered part of the political community, despite historical perspectives on age of majority.
    • Noncitizens: The rights of noncitizens, particularly those unlawfully present, to bear arms under the Second Amendment are contested. The 5th Circuit in United States v. Medina-Cantu found that noncitizens unlawfully present are not part of “the people,” whereas the 6th Circuit in United States v. Escobar-Temal acknowledged possible inclusion based on substantial connections with the country.

In conclusion, who constitutes “the people” eligible for Second Amendment protections remains an evolving question. It hinges on interpretations of the political community and the application of rights within the United States legal framework, as explored in SCOTUS Blog’s analysis. The evolving judgments reflect broader legal and societal shifts impacting this dynamic constitutional issue.