The Supreme Court has decided not to grant the Trump administration’s request to enforce certain aspects of a new rule on mail-in voting through the U.S. Postal Service. This decision maintains the order of a federal judge in Boston, which restricts the implementation of the rule. This comes just weeks before the midterm elections, with two states, North Carolina and Alabama, already dispatching mail ballots.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh supported the Court’s decision, acknowledging that although the Postal Service might have the authority to announce such a rule, there isn’t enough time for election officials to effectively implement it before the elections. On the other hand, Justice Samuel Alito, joined by Justice Clarence Thomas, dissented, questioning the legal standing of some challengers and critiquing the claims as unlikely to succeed. For more details, see the Supreme Court’s brief order.
The Trump administration previously sought to impose this rule as part of an executive order aimed at tackling voter fraud. The order had set obligations on various federal bodies to take specific steps concerning mail-in voting rights. U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani had imposed restrictions on this executive order, arguing it conflicted with constitutional provisions granting states the power to manage voter eligibility and the organization of congressional elections. This was subsequently contested by a coalition of 23 states and the District of Columbia, leading to ongoing litigation.
U.S. Solicitor General D. John Sauer contended against Judge Talwani’s preliminary injunction, which indefinitely restrains the government from enforcing the Postal Service’s rule while legal proceedings continue. He argued that the rule only sets modest requirements for ballot envelope design and addressee information via USPS, asserting that its implementation wouldn’t “federalize” the rules for mail-in voting. Despite this, states are permitted to distribute ballots not meeting the rule’s criteria if the stay is not granted.
This legal battle has drawn varied reactions. The states challenging the rule have noted that enforcing it could result in complications, citing potential chaos with millions potentially unable to vote by mail. In support of this concern, a brief from state and local election officials, including several Republican secretaries of state, highlighted risks of mistakes and confusion.
The Supreme Court’s determination that the government is unlikely to succeed in its appeal against Talwani’s injunction weighed heavily in the denial. The decision also factored in the potential harms if the injunction were to be stayed, which the Court indicated do not favor the government’s request. For a full overview, visit the full article.