The Supreme Court has recently declined to review several significant cases, notably issues revolving around diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), as well as a Second Amendment challenge to firearms regulation. Among the cases not taken up is the Trump v. Thakur conflict, where University of California scholars disputed cuts to research funding tied to DEI initiatives. This case emerged after President Donald Trump, in his second term, issued executive orders leading to federal agencies cutting funding for projects linked to DEI.
The scholars argued these cuts violated free speech and due process rights. Initially, a federal district court ruled against the administration, but the Supreme Court’s recent decision allows the 9th Circuit’s upholding of the ban to stand without setting a national precedent, as the court refused to engage further with the case.
Another rejected case involved Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist, who challenged the state’s requirement that continuing medical education include implicit bias training, focusing again on free speech concerns. The Khatibi v. Yip case was brought to question whether such a mandate constitutes government overreach into private speech. Both U.S. District and the 9th Circuit courts previously upheld the requirement.
The court also denied review of Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on guns in “sensitive places” such as government buildings and public transportation. This decision places weight on the 4th Circuit’s ruling, relying on principles from the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, affirming that carrying firearms in sensitive places may be lawfully restricted.
Justice Clarence Thomas expressed skepticism about the consistency of these restrictions with historical firearm regulations but noted the broad scope of the challenge in Novotny might hinder Supreme Court deliberations. Should a narrower case arise, the Court might then explore states’ authority to designate sensitive places for firearms prohibition.
The Court’s decisions from its orders list also invited the United States solicitor general to share views on cases against the Taliban, related to terrorist attacks, yet it remains silent on how these would affect the interpretation of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act and the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act. The orders reflect a cautious approach to engage with politically sensitive or constitutionally complex issues, leaving existing lower court decisions in place.
For additional insights into the Supreme Court’s recent actions, access the comprehensive report here.