Court Hears Amy Wax’s Appeal Against University of Pennsylvania: A Legal Clash Over Free Speech and Institutional Sanctions

On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit convened to hear oral arguments in the case of Amy Wax v. The Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania. Representing Professor Wax was John Eastman, a conservative attorney and former adviser to President Donald Trump. The proceedings marked a significant juncture in the ongoing legal dispute between Wax and the University of Pennsylvania.

Amy Wax, a tenured professor at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School, has been a polarizing figure due to her public remarks concerning race and immigration. In September 2024, the university imposed sanctions on Wax, citing “flagrant unprofessional conduct.” These sanctions included a one-year suspension at half pay, removal of her named chair, and a public reprimand. The university’s actions were based on findings that Wax had made derogatory generalizations about various groups, including those defined by race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and immigration status. ([almanac.upenn.edu](https://almanac.upenn.edu/articles/final-determination-of-complaint-against-professor-amy-wax?utm_source=openai))

In response, Wax filed a lawsuit in January 2025, alleging that the university’s actions violated her civil rights and constituted a breach of contract. She contended that the university’s speech policies were inconsistently applied and discriminated against her based on her race. However, in August 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania dismissed her claims, stating that Wax failed to demonstrate that her race was a factor in the disciplinary process. ([cases.justia.com](https://cases.justia.com/federal/district-courts/pennsylvania/paedce/2%3A2025cv00269/632266/55/0.pdf?utm_source=openai))

During the recent appellate hearing, Eastman argued that the university’s sanctions against Wax were a result of a double standard, asserting that other faculty members had made more egregious statements without facing similar repercussions. He claimed that by punishing Wax for her comments on affirmative action, the university violated Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, which prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin in programs receiving federal assistance. ([thedp.com](https://www.thedp.com/article/2026/11/penn-amy-wax-oral-arguments-court-discrimination-lawsuit?utm_source=openai))

The university’s counsel, Michael Kenneally of Morgan Lewis, countered that Wax’s legal team had abandoned the argument regarding the alleged double standard in their appellate filing. He emphasized that the appellate argument needed to be consistent with the claims presented in the district court. Kenneally also highlighted that Wax’s prolonged history of making controversial statements, both within and outside the classroom, distinguished her case from other faculty members. ([thedp.com](https://www.thedp.com/article/2026/11/penn-amy-wax-oral-arguments-court-discrimination-lawsuit?utm_source=openai))

Judge Thomas Hardiman expressed skepticism toward Eastman’s approach, suggesting that the case appeared to be a First Amendment claim being reframed as a civil rights issue. He remarked, “You’re trying to shoehorn a free speech case into something else. We are dealing with a private university.” ([news.bloomberglaw.com](https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/third-circuit-grills-ex-trump-lawyer-in-professors-bias-case?utm_source=openai))

The appellate court’s decision will have significant implications for the balance between academic freedom and institutional standards within private universities. As the legal proceedings continue, the case underscores the complexities surrounding free speech, discrimination, and the responsibilities of academic institutions.