As the U.S. Supreme Court continues to ponder how to balance two of the most significant constitutional rights, the First Amendment’s protection of the free exercise of religion and the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause, legal experts are questioning whether these rights should be approached differently. This query was brought into focus during the oral arguments in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a case that is likely to test the boundaries of these constitutional protections.
The debate centers on whether proving discrimination under the free exercise clause should be easier than under equal protection. Historically, the Supreme Court has maintained that disparate impact alone does not suffice to prove discrimination under the equal protection clause. However, several conservative justices suggested that the discriminatory impact against a religion should be enough for a law to be struck down, potentially signaling a shift in jurisprudence.
The case of Employment Division v. Smith set a precedent that the free exercise clause cannot challenge a neutral law of general applicability unless there is intent to discriminate against religion. On the other hand, the Sherbert v. Verner decision suggested that a law’s impact on religious exercise could indeed merit heightened scrutiny, setting the stage for ongoing debate.
These discussions carry significant implications, particularly in cases like St. Mary Catholic Parish, where a Colorado law requiring non-discrimination in preschool admissions is being challenged on religious grounds. The Carson v. Makin decision invalidated similar restrictions in Maine, and Colorado’s law is now under the microscope for comparable reasons.
The tension also raises questions about the conceptual justification for treating religious discrimination differently from race or sex discrimination. Historically, the Court has insisted that discriminatory purpose requires intent to disadvantage a group, not merely knowledge of a law’s unequal impact, as articulated in Personnel Administrator of Massachusetts v. Feeney.
Legal scholars argue that if the judicial approach deviates from established equal protection principles to favor religious claims, it might pave the way for a unique doctrinal path privileging religious exercise. As the Court deliberates, many wonder if this would result in what some describe as “free exercise exceptionalism.”
For more detailed coverage on this issue, the full-length article is available at SCOTUSblog.