“The Political Roots of the U.S. Supreme Court: Revisiting a 19th-Century Legacy”

In her recent publication, “The Political Supreme Court: A Forgotten History”, historian Rachel A. Shelden presents a compelling re-examination of the U.S. Supreme Court during the 19th century, challenging the widely held contemporary perception of the court as an apolitical institution. Chief Justice John Roberts’ assertion that political branches should not dictate the law reflects a modern perspective Shelden scrutinizes, suggesting that it is not as deeply rooted in the court’s history as assumed.

Drawing from historical anecdotes, Shelden outlines a period when justices were entangled in political life, often influencing or directly participating in political discourse. For instance, Chief Justice John Marshall was notably active before and during his tenure on the bench, contributing to the Washington Federalist, a Federalist newspaper. Justice William Johnson took it upon himself to disseminate a pamphlet defending his judicial opinions, bypassing the conventional routes censored by local officials.

The political motives of many justices extended beyond editorial input. Several pursued elected office while serving as justices. Justice Smith Thompson ran for governor of New York in 1828 without stepping down from the bench, although he was ultimately defeated by Martin Van Buren. Similarly, Justice John McLean was considered for the presidency in the 1830s even as he adjudicated cases.

These historical narratives contrast sharply with today’s expectations of judicial conduct, where modern justices almost unanimously reject political entanglements. Yet, Shelden’s work reveals that the evolution toward the present-day concept of judicial neutrality may not be as linear or traditional as some may assume. Rather, it appears to be an adaptation reflecting the legal and societal shifts at the turn of the century.

The book prompts reflections on whether the court’s retreat from political life has served American democracy well or if past practices held certain advantages. This transition to a more isolated judiciary signals significant change over time—a change that she suggests was driven by evolving views of the court’s role, rather than an ahistorical tradition.

Shelden’s analysis extends an invitation to reconsider not only the court’s past but also its potential future. Her work raises pertinent questions about the potential for renewed intertwining of judicial duties with political engagement, a path once prevalent but now cautiously scrutinized.

For more insights into the remarkable journey of judicial politics, you can access further details through SCOTUSblog.