Global Call to Reform Loopholes in Incendiary Weapons Treaty Amid Rising Concerns

A coalition of 11 human rights and civil society organizations recently called upon nations to address critical gaps in the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) regarding incendiary weapons. Adopted in 1980, the CCW is a UN treaty intended to regulate certain weapons known to cause unnecessary suffering, particularly those affecting civilians. Protocol III of the CCW specifically governs incendiary weapons, defining them as munitions designed to ignite objects or cause burn injuries through flame or heat. However, the treaty’s current language contains loopholes that continue to be exploited.

The call for reform, spearheaded by Human Rights Watch (HRW) at the CCW’s Seventh Review Conference, was supported by entities like Amnesty International and Harvard Law School’s International Human Rights Clinic. Their joint statement highlights that the definition of incendiary weapons is narrowly focused on the weapon’s primary design, thus excluding multipurpose munitions like white phosphorus. Although white phosphorus is generally used for generating smoke or illumination, its deployment as a weapon can result in severe burns, as reported by Jurist.

The statement further argues that discrepancies in restrictions placed on different delivery methods need addressing. Specifically, ground-launched incendiary weapons face fewer restrictions than air-dropped ones, despite their similarly devastating impact on civilian populations. HRW’s Bonnie Docherty emphasized the humanitarian imperative of revising these provisions, which have remained unchanged for 46 years, even though a review was committed to five years ago.

White phosphorus, notorious for causing burns that can penetrate to the bone and reignite, epitomizes the inadequacies of the current regulations. A 2024 HRW report documented the weapons’ use in conflict zones such as Gaza, Ukraine, and Syria, with recent incidents observed in Lebanon. Given these findings, human rights advocates are urging nations to not only condemn the use of such weapons but also to implement stronger international laws to curb their use.

Efforts to reform the protocols on incendiary weapons come amid broader discussions about the need for stronger regulations on conventional weapons. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has also stressed the importance of adapting legal frameworks to reflect the evolving nature of warfare and its impact on civilians. With increasing reports of incendiary weapon use in global conflicts, the coalition’s demand for action underscores an urgent need for international commitments that hold humanitarian considerations at their core, as discussed in a recent analysis.