Delaware Judge Orders New Damages Trial in Patent Infringement Case

In a recent ruling, a Delaware federal judge has concurred to institute a new trial on damages in a patent infringement case involving a German software firm. Previously, a jury had dictated the software company to compensate $5.7 million to a lesser competitor for unauthorised use of two patents. These patents were specific to the remote access of Apple operating systems.

The judge’s decision was influenced by the quality of submissions from both sides which she indicated were so inadequate they neared being laughable. Despite the gravity of the case, it was evident the details were not thoroughly outlined and scrutinized.

Such judicial decisions could create a precedent for future trials especially where briefing quality is questionable or where the quantum of damages in intellectual property litigation is under evaluation.

For more in-depth details of the original deliberation, you can access the court documentation recorded on Law360.